More importantly, formula and product design matter — especially if you're trying to pull off a particularly graphic liner look. Water-resistant and waterproof eyeliner pencils are a must when you're applying color to a perpetually wet part of your eye area. Whether you're going for the Margot Tenenbaum aesthetic, the my-lashes-but-better tightline, or the crayoned-on angsty mall-goth vibe, the best eyeliners will comfortably cling to your waterline all day. Thrive causemetics infinity waterproof eyeliner Belle Beauty by Kim Gravel So Shady Longwear Shadow Stick Trio

On the plus side: no pencil sharpener needed! Accessibility Notice Is the Thrive Causemetics Smart Microdermabrasion 2-in-1 Instant Facial safe for pregnancy?

Cool Cat Eye Starting with a freshly sharpened eyeliner point, draw a clean line beginning at the inner corner of your eyelid and follow the lash line to the outer edge, extending just past your last lash to create a wing. GET FREE SAMPLES So long as it’s an easy-to-remove waterproof eyeliner (like the ones in our top tier), a quick swipe of micellar water will do the trick. Simply dip a cotton swab into micellar water and swipe it across the liner error. If you’re traveling or prefer fewer steps, you can use Alleyoop’s Tip-Off Liquid Filled Makeup Removing Swabs, in which you just have to crack off the tip, let the other tip fill with liquid, and swipe accordingly.

Review:I ordered two eye liner from Thrive for it said it is not going to run. It is very dark and easy to apply. But I am disappointed it smears and not staying as well as I hoped. I also ordered a cream eye line pencil from sheseiido marjelico majori o cream pencil that was much cheaper. It worked as well Thrive or better. It do smear a little too. That was why I switched to order from thrive and hoped it will do better. I let it stayed for 30 second or longer, it did work in the morning. It smeared after 4 hours. The price is so expensive and I thought it should be better. But, don’t waste your $. Read more Under Eye Concealer Swatches – Part 1 These smudge-proof liquid and pencil eyeliners will never ghost you.